November 17, 2026

AFJ Voices | The True History of Mass Incarceration in America — Part 8

Part 7 of our series, The True History of Mass Incarceration in America, explored how the deaths of Breonna Taylor and George Floyd catalyzed one of the largest global protest movements in modern history. Although those protests prompted limited policy shifts, the systemic structures driving these fatal encounters year after year remain fundamentally unaltered.

By 2021, the United States had experienced one of the largest movements for racial justice in its history. Millions of Americans had demanded changes to policing, greater accountability for misconduct, and a reconsideration of the country's reliance on incarceration. Elected officials promised reform, corporations pledged support for racial equity, and conversations about systemic racism reached institutions that had rarely acknowledged their role in perpetuating inequality.

Yet the years that followed revealed a persistent contradiction in American history. The reality is that widespread recognition of injustice does not necessarily produce the political will to change the institutions responsible for it. Between 2021 and 2026, efforts to reform the criminal legal system encountered political resistance, renewed tough-on-crime policies, and expanding forms of detention. While some reforms advanced and incarceration remained below its historical peak, the systems responsible for criminalizing and disproportionately punishing African American and Hispanic communities continued to exercise enormous influence.

2021: Reform Momentum Meets Institutional Resistance

In 2021, the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act represented one of the most significant federal attempts to address police misconduct and accountability in decades. The legislation proposed restrictions on certain policing practices, greater transparency, and changes to the legal protections that make it difficult to hold officers accountable for constitutional violations. Despite passing the House of Representatives, the legislation stalled in the Senate. Negotiations between lawmakers ultimately collapsed, demonstrating how quickly the political momentum for reform could encounter institutional resistance.

At the same time, the COVID-19 pandemic had produced an unexpected development within the criminal legal system. Prison and jail populations declined as courts slowed operations, arrests decreased in some jurisdictions, and correctional authorities implemented emergency measures to reduce overcrowding. These reductions demonstrated that significant changes in incarceration levels were possible. However, many of those reductions proved temporary. As pandemic restrictions eased, incarceration began increasing again in numerous jurisdictions. According to research by the Vera Institute of Justice, by 2024, incarceration had returned to pre-pandemic levels in many states and rural counties.

The Biden administration pursued some reforms, including changes to federal policies and efforts to address racial disparities. Nevertheless, most incarcerated Americans remained under state and local jurisdiction, beyond the direct reach of federal reforms. The fundamental structures of policing, prosecution, sentencing, and incarceration remained largely intact.

2022: The Return of Tough-on-Crime Politics

By 2022, the national conversation about criminal justice had begun shifting. Concerns about violent crime, public disorder, and community safety became increasingly prominent in political campaigns and public debate. Although crime trends varied considerably across jurisdictions, public perceptions of rising danger helped generate renewed support for aggressive policing, expanded enforcement, and tougher sentencing policies.

The language of public safety became a powerful political instrument. Discussions about bail reform, youth crime, and alternatives to incarceration frequently centered on whether reforms had made communities less safe, often without adequately distinguishing between individual policies and broader social conditions. This debate carried particular historical significance. For generations, portrayals of Black and Brown communities as dangerous had influenced public support for punitive policies. The renewed emphasis on crime and punishment raised questions about how those longstanding perceptions continued to shape contemporary political decisions.

The courts also placed limits on accountability. In Egbert v. Boule, the U.S. Supreme Court further restricted the circumstances under which individuals could seek financial damages from federal officers for alleged constitutional violations. The decision reinforced the legal obstacles facing people seeking remedies for certain forms of government misconduct. Meanwhile, electronic monitoring increasingly became part of the conversation about alternatives to incarceration. Although monitoring can allow individuals to remain in their communities rather than in jail, restrictive conditions, surveillance, and the possibility of reincarceration for violations raised questions about whether these approaches represented greater freedom or simply different forms of control.

2023: Mass Incarceration Evolves Rather Than Disappears

The end of the federal COVID-19 public health emergency in May 2023 marked another transition. Temporary policies introduced during the pandemic were reassessed, while the longer-term questions raised about overcrowding, public health, and the necessity of incarceration remained unresolved.

The private prison industry continued adapting to changing government priorities. Companies historically associated with operating prisons and detention centers increasingly emphasized broader correctional services, including electronic monitoring, transportation, rehabilitation programs, and immigration detention. This evolution reflected a larger transformation in the business of incarceration. Even when fewer people were held in traditional prisons, private companies could continue generating revenue through contracts connected to detention, supervision, and correctional services.

The treatment of young people remained another significant concern. After decades of declining youth incarceration, national research documented increases in youth confinement in 2022 and 2023. At the same time, some states pursued policies making it easier to prosecute certain young people as adults or impose more punitive responses to youth offenses. These developments highlighted a recurring tension in American juvenile justice. Whether young people should be treated primarily as individuals capable of development and rehabilitation or subjected to punishment that can shape the remainder of their lives.

2024: The Politics of Punishment Reassert Themselves

During the 2024 presidential election, crime, immigration, and public safety became prominent political issues. Proposals to expand law enforcement authority, increase penalties for certain offenses, and reverse criminal justice reforms reflected the continuing influence of punitive approaches to public safety. In New York City, the ongoing crisis at Rikers Island illustrated the difficulty of transforming deeply entrenched institutions. Despite the city's commitment to closing the jail complex, delays in constructing replacement facilities, continued concerns about conditions, and political disagreements made the future of the closure plan increasingly uncertain. Rikers had become a symbol of the consequences of prolonged pretrial detention, inadequate mental health care, violence, and institutional dysfunction.

The national data revealed similarly troubling patterns. According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, approximately 659,000 people were held in local jails at midyear 2024. Of those individuals, 68 percent had not been convicted of a crime.

Racial disparities remained substantial. Black Americans were incarcerated in local jails at a rate of 566 per 100,000 residents, compared with 149 per 100,000 white residents—nearly four times the rate.

These figures demonstrated that incarceration was not solely a consequence of criminal convictions. Decisions about arrests, bail, pretrial detention, and access to legal resources continued to determine who remained behind bars.

For individuals experiencing poverty, unstable housing, or serious mental health challenges, those decisions could have consequences extending far beyond a court appearance.

2025: The Crisis Persists Under a New Name

By 2025, the United States continued to incarcerate nearly two million people across prisons, jails, immigration detention facilities, and other confinement systems. Although the prison population remained below its peak, the broader reach of the criminal legal system extended well beyond physical incarceration. Millions of Americans lived under probation or parole supervision, while electronic monitoring, court-imposed financial obligations, and restrictions associated with criminal records affected their ability to work, secure housing, and rebuild their lives.

The distinction between incarceration and freedom was increasingly complicated by systems that allowed individuals to live outside correctional facilities while remaining subject to extensive government supervision.

Significant changes also occurred in federal enforcement priorities, particularly in the areas of immigration enforcement and detention. Federal authorities pursued expanded detention and deportation policies, contributing to renewed growth in the number of people confined under federal immigration authority. These developments intensified longstanding debates about the relationship between immigration enforcement, racial inequality, private detention contracts, and the expansion of government power. Meanwhile, advocates continued challenging the assumption that incarceration was the most effective response to social problems. Community organizations, researchers, and reform movements increasingly emphasized the importance of investments in education, housing, healthcare, employment, and community-based approaches to public safety.

2026: The Expanding Reach of Detention and Punishment

By 2026, new research illustrated how the landscape of mass incarceration was continuing to change.

The Prison Policy Initiative's Mass Incarceration: The Whole Pie 2026 reported that nearly two million people remained confined across the nation's incarceration and detention systems. When probation and parole were included, more than five million people were under some form of correctional control. One of the most significant developments was the expansion of immigration detention. Between the reporting periods used in the organization's 2025 and 2026 analyses, the number of people held by Immigration and Customs Enforcement increased by approximately 25,200, or 58 percent. This growth accounted for virtually all the increase in the total confined population between those reports. It also demonstrated that the expansion of confinement was not occurring uniformly across the criminal legal system.

Immigration detention is legally distinct from incarceration following a criminal conviction. Nevertheless, both rely on detention facilities, government enforcement authority, and, in many cases, private contractors.

The financial dimensions of the system were equally significant. The Prison Policy Initiative estimated that the broader criminal legal system cost approximately $445 billion annually, including expenditures associated with policing, courts, incarceration, and related activities.

These figures raised fundamental questions about national priorities. The country continued to devote extraordinary resources to systems of punishment and supervision while communities struggled to secure adequate investments in housing, mental health services, education, and economic opportunity.

The racial disparities documented throughout this historical series also remained deeply embedded. Despite decades of reform efforts, Black Americans continued to experience disproportionately high rates of incarceration.

The Future of Justice

The history of mass incarceration in America is not simply a history of prisons. It is a history of decisions about whose behavior is criminalized, whose freedom is restricted, and which communities receive investment rather than punishment.

From the laws that criminalized Black people during slavery and Reconstruction to the expansion of prisons during the War on Drugs, American institutions have repeatedly relied on punishment to address social conditions rooted in racial and economic inequality.

The developments between 2021 and 2026 demonstrate that these patterns have not disappeared. They have evolved through changing policies, technologies, political narratives, and enforcement priorities.

Yet this history also reveals that change is possible. Incarceration rates have declined from their historical peaks. Reforms have altered sentencing practices, expanded opportunities for reentry, and reduced confinement in some jurisdictions. Community-based organizations have demonstrated that rehabilitation, education, employment, and sustained personal support can offer meaningful alternatives to incarceration.

The question confronting America is whether these approaches will remain exceptions within a system built around punishment or become central to how the country understands justice and public safety.

After more than four centuries of policies that have disproportionately criminalized Black and Brown Americans, the future of justice will depend not only on changing laws, but also on changing the assumptions, priorities, and investments that have sustained mass incarceration for generations.

Timeline: Major Developments, 2021–2026

2021 — Federal Police Reform Stalls: The George Floyd Justice in Policing Act passes the House but fails to advance through the Senate, illustrating the political obstacles to national police accountability legislation.

2021 — Pandemic-Era Incarceration Reductions Begin to Reverse: As emergency measures ease, prison and jail populations begin increasing in some jurisdictions.

2022 — Tough-on-Crime Politics Regain Influence: Public concerns about crime become prominent in political campaigns, renewing debates over policing, bail reform, and sentencing.

June 2022 — Supreme Court Restricts Federal Officer Accountability: In Egbert v. Boule, the Court further limits the circumstances in which individuals may seek damages from federal officers for constitutional violations.

2022–2023 — Youth Confinement Increases: National research documents increases in youth confinement following decades of declining juvenile incarceration.

May 2023 — Federal COVID-19 Public Health Emergency Ends: Emergency policies are reassessed as questions about incarceration, public health, and reentry remain unresolved.

2023 — Correctional Supervision and Private Detention Services Evolve: Electronic monitoring, immigration detention, and contracted correctional services remain significant components of the broader incarceration system.

2024 — Rikers Island Closure Remains Uncertain: New York City's efforts to replace the jail complex continue to face delays, political challenges, and concerns about conditions.

2024 — Racial Disparities and Pretrial Detention Persist: Federal data show that Black Americans are incarcerated in local jails at nearly four times the rate of white Americans, while 68 percent of people held in local jails have not been convicted.

2025 — Immigration Enforcement and Detention Expand: Changes in federal immigration policy contribute to increasing detention populations.

March 2026 — National Incarceration Report Documents Expanding Detention: The Prison Policy Initiative reports that ICE detention increased by 58 percent between its 2025 and 2026 reporting periods.

2026 — Mass Incarceration Remains a Defining National Challenge: Nearly two million people remain confined, while millions more live under correctional supervision. The country continues debating the relationship between punishment, racial inequality, and public safety.

JOIN OUR NEWSLETTER

Stay up to date with AFJ!

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.