
Avenues for Justice
100 Centre Street, Room 1541
New York, NY 10013
info@avenuesforjustice.org

In Part 6 of our series, The True History of Mass Incarceration in America, we explored how the conversation around incarceration shifted in the early 21st century. Criminal justice reform gained momentum, the United States elected its first Black president, Barack Obama, and social media brought greater visibility to police brutality and longstanding demands for accountability. These developments also met strong cultural backlash.
Part 7 brings us to 2020, when George Floyd’s murder brought millions of people into the streets and renewed demands for change. To understand that moment, we must consider both what happened to Floyd and the history that preceded it.
On May 25, 2020, George Floyd at the age of 46-year-old was murdered by a Minneapolis police officer during an arrest. Officer Derek Chauvin pressed his knee against Floyd's neck for more than nine minutes as Floyd lay handcuffed on the ground. Floyd repeatedly said that he could not breathe. Bystanders pleaded with the officers to intervene, but Floyd eventually became unresponsive.
The encounter was recorded on a cellphone, and the video spread rapidly across social media and news outlets. Within days, protests erupted in cities throughout the United States and around the world. Floyd's murder became one of the most consequential events in the modern history of racial justice in America. But understanding why requires looking beyond the circumstances of his death.
George Floyd was not the first Black man killed by police. His murder followed decades of documented police violence, racial profiling, discriminatory law enforcement practices, and unequal treatment within the criminal legal system.
For generations, Black Americans had challenged these injustices through organizing, protests, legal action, and demands for accountability. Yet many of the same patterns continued.
What made 2020 different was the combination of events taking place across the country and the extraordinary scale of the public response.
When George Floyd was murdered, the United States was experiencing the COVID-19 pandemic. Millions of Americans were living under restrictions intended to limit the spread of the virus. Businesses and schools had closed, unemployment had risen dramatically, and families were confronting widespread uncertainty. The pandemic also exposed longstanding racial and economic inequalities. Black Americans and other communities of color experienced disproportionate rates of illness, hospitalization, and death, reflecting inequalities in healthcare access, employment, housing, and exposure to health risks. At the same time, the pandemic created a public health crisis inside jails and prisons.
Incarcerated people often lived in crowded conditions where physical distancing was difficult or impossible. Access to healthcare was limited, and many facilities struggled to control the spread of infection. The crisis raised urgent questions about why so many people were incarcerated, particularly individuals being held before trial, people serving sentences for nonviolent offenses, and older individuals with serious health conditions. For some Americans, the pandemic brought new attention to the relationship between incarceration, poverty, race, and public health.
Just two months before George Floyd's murder, Breonna Taylor, a 26-year-old Black emergency medical technician, was shot and killed by police officers inside her Louisville, Kentucky, apartment. On March 13, 2020, officers entered Taylor's home while executing a search warrant connected to a drug investigation. Her boyfriend, Kenneth Walker, fired a shot, saying he believed intruders were entering the apartment. Police returned fire, striking Taylor multiple times.
No drugs were found in her apartment. Taylor's death generated widespread public outrage and renewed scrutiny of police search warrants, the use of force, and accountability when law enforcement operations result in the deaths of civilians. Her name became central to the protests that followed George Floyd's murder. Together, their deaths intensified a national conversation about the ways Black Americans could encounter danger during interactions with law enforcement, whether on a public street or inside their own homes.
The protests that followed George Floyd's murder were extraordinary in their size and geographic reach. Demonstrations took place in major cities, small towns, and communities across the United States. Millions of people participated, including individuals who had never previously attended a protest. The demonstrations also spread internationally, with people gathering in cities throughout Europe, Africa, Asia, Australia, and the Americas.
Protesters demanded accountability for police violence and called for changes to the institutions and policies that had contributed to racial inequality. The Black Lives Matter movement, established in 2013, became a central organizing force in this national and international response.
Although the movement had already brought attention to the deaths of Trayvon Martin, Michael Brown, Eric Garner, Tamir Rice, and many others, the events of 2020 brought its message to a much larger audience. For many participants, the protests were not solely about George Floyd or Breonna Taylor. They reflected years of frustration over racial discrimination, unequal treatment, and the continuing consequences of America's history of criminalizing Black people.
The demonstrations also brought new attention to the relationship between policing and mass incarceration.
Understanding the Connection Between Policing and Incarceration
The decisions made at each stage of the criminal legal system influence who is arrested, who remains in jail while awaiting trial, who receives legal representation, and who ultimately receives a prison sentence. These decisions can have consequences that extend far beyond incarceration. This is one reason the protests of 2020 led to broader discussions about the purpose of policing, the use of incarceration, and the need for investments in communities.
The debate was not simply about whether individual police officers should be held accountable. It was also about the policies and institutions that shaped their authority and the consequences of that authority.
As protests continued, elected officials, community organizations, advocates, and policymakers proposed a wide range of responses. Some called for changes to police training, greater accountability, restrictions on certain uses of force, and stronger oversight of law enforcement agencies. Others argued that these reforms were insufficient because they did not address the larger conditions that contributed to criminalization and incarceration. They called for greater investment in housing, education, employment, healthcare, mental health services, and community-based responses to crises.
These different approaches reflected an important debate about the meaning of public safety. One perspective emphasized improving the accountability and effectiveness of existing institutions. Another emphasized reducing reliance on policing and incarceration by addressing the social and economic conditions that contribute to harm. Although the approaches differed, the events of 2020 forced a much broader public discussion about whether the country had invested too heavily in punishment and too little in prevention and community well-being.
For much of American history, newspapers, television networks, and other established media organizations largely determined which stories received public attention. The growth of smartphones and social media gave ordinary people new ways to document encounters with law enforcement and share information directly with the public. The video of George Floyd's murder became a powerful example of how this technology could challenge official accounts and make incidents of police violence visible to millions of people.
But visibility did not automatically produce accountability. Although public pressure led to investigations, prosecutions, and policy proposals, broader changes to the criminal legal system remained difficult.
The country was confronted with the fact that exposing injustice is not the same as eliminating the conditions that allow it to continue.
The events of 2020 changed the national conversation about race and the criminal legal system. Millions of Americans became more familiar with terms such as systemic racism, racial profiling, mass incarceration, and criminal justice reform. Organizations, corporations, universities, and government institutions publicly acknowledged racial inequalities and announced new commitments to diversity, equity, and racial justice.
The protests also increased public attention to the experiences of incarcerated people, the treatment of individuals by law enforcement, and the importance of community-based alternatives to incarceration. But public awareness and institutional statements were not the same as lasting structural change.
The policies that had contributed to mass incarceration remained largely in place. Racial disparities continued throughout the criminal legal system, and debates about policing and punishment became increasingly contentious.
The events of 2020 demonstrated the power of public organizing and collective action. They also exposed how difficult it would be to translate demands for change into lasting policy reforms.
The national debate had expanded beyond individual cases of police violence to include the larger systems that shaped criminalization and punishment. But the institutions responsible for policing, prosecution, sentencing, and incarceration remained largely intact.
The history of mass incarceration demonstrates that changing public attitudes does not automatically change public policy. Throughout American history, periods of progress have often been followed by political opposition, new forms of discrimination, and renewed support for punitive approaches to crime.
But the years that follow reveal how difficult it is to transform systems that have developed over generations.
March — COVID-19 Pandemic Expands Across the United States: The pandemic exposes severe public health risks in jails and prisons, raising questions about overcrowding, healthcare access, and the necessity of incarceration for certain populations.
March 13 — Breonna Taylor Killed by Police: Breonna Taylor, a 26-year-old emergency medical technician, is fatally shot by police officers during a search warrant operation at her home in Louisville, Kentucky.
May 25 — George Floyd Murdered: Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin murders George Floyd during an arrest. Video of the encounter spreads rapidly, generating international outrage.
May 26 and Following Weeks — Nationwide Protests Begin: Demonstrations demanding accountability for police violence spread throughout the United States and eventually around the world.
June — National Debate Over Policing and Public Investment Intensifies: Policymakers, community organizations, and advocates debate police accountability, funding priorities, and the role of community-based approaches to addressing harm.
June 12 — Rayshard Brooks Killed by Police: Rayshard Brooks, a 27-year-old Black man, is fatally shot by an Atlanta police officer, prompting additional protests and scrutiny of police use of force.
Summer 2020 — Racial Justice Demonstrations Continue: Millions of people participate in protests addressing police violence, systemic racism, and racial inequality.
September 2020 — Breonna Taylor Case Generates Renewed Protests: A Kentucky grand jury's decisions concerning charges against officers involved in the police operation led to renewed demonstrations and questions about accountability.
December 2020 — A Year of Protest and Unresolved Demands: The country ends the year with heightened public awareness of racial inequality, but many proposed federal reforms remain unresolved.